rscholar wrote: ↑Mon Jul 07, 2025 4:26 am
eddiegiantman wrote: ↑Mon Jul 07, 2025 2:52 am
Pretty sure Scidram wasn't this hyped for Gen V and Emma and he was looking forward to that so you know this got them somewhere special.
Well comparatively speaking, we're talking about:
-Misfit super-human side character for whom shrinking and powers are the norm, can (for the most part) control and choose when to shrink, isn't considered particularly special and doesn't wield any real influence or power other than her limited fanbase, all within a series in which she wasn't the main focus and her powers and size adventures would feature even less (sex scene and out-of-clothes scene notwithstanding) and was conceived as an original character we could not research or infer much about until the show gave us anything.
Vs.
-Normal woman in a world where size tech is known but still novel, is seemingly important and successful, and for whom being shrunk is accidental, dramatic, and possibly permanent, in a series that revolves *explicitly* around this incident and world-builds her and her relationships before, during, and after the accident, and will promise emotionally charged power struggles with her husband and how they see each other, conceived based on a short-story a number of us have read and can compare and contrast with emerging info about the show to imagine what will be new or recreated (i.e. are we going to see Elizabeth Banks creeping around her house like a tiny feral huntress skewering flies like in the book?)
I mean, I'm looking forward to Gen V too and I literally have to stop and remind myself that it's even happening because I'm also hyper-focused on any news on Miniature Wife. It's like comparing a live-action Tinkerbell in Peter Pan vs. The Incredible Shrinking Woman - having both is obviously great but one just has a lot more going on than the other.
rscholar pretty much hit the nail on the head.
When
Gen V came out, it was the big thing not only because it featured a shrinking woman but also because of THAT scene. Never did we expect to see something like that produced by a mainstream broadcaster. That scene notwithstanding, we've spent how long scrounging the crumbs of SW scenes? Apart from the scenes with Emma,
Gen V as a show doesn't really do much for me. I watched the whole first season--and I'll watch the second season when it comes out--just to see anything there is, but that's about it.
The Miniature Wife is something far different than that, as Lindy being shrunk is going to be the main through line of the entire series. When I think of all the movies we've seen that have focused on a shrunken woman character, we get either the likes of
Help, I Shrunk My Teacher/Parents series, which is essentially a children's movie or
The Incredible Shrinking Woman which has some great moments but otherwise goes off the rails from the plot it establishes.
The Miniature Wife stands to focus on how being shrunk affects Lindy's psyche, and we've never had anything like that before. The fact that it's a series (10+ episodes, based on my research) as opposed to an under 2-hour movie guarantees that we're going to view the most prolonged experience of a woman being shrunk. And finally, I'm in my early 50s, and so is Elizabeth Banks, so this scenario feels not only age-appropriate to me but also the most relatable. And not gonna deny that she looks great.
So yeah, this gets me somewhere special.
