Shrink Fan Disappointment

[Nropyub]

Been a long time supporter off and on of Shrink fan and Giantess Fan. I think they’re losing me for good. Am I alone in this?

We’re getting a lot of story based comics but the stories are told one issue per month with a long gap between issues. Many times stories are just abandoned.

And a lot of them spend the whole first issue setting up the tiny parts, so we don’t even see them.

Additionally more often than not lately their stories feature almost all women so I feel like I’m just reading lesbian giantess content because it’s emphasizing the larger person.

The art seems more rushed and less detailed lately.

The only story they seem to be committed to hammering in is going nowhere and features a ton of weird body stretching and again features only women (the superhero one). They emphasize repeated shrinking scenes in plain voids with only another woman to compare scale to. I just don’t get it.

I dunno. I just don’t see who they have in mind for this anymore.

[Raso719]

They do tend to structure stuff in a way where the first issue has way too much set up to the point the action is all in the second half of the comic. I wish they had more without 10 pages if exposition and just got right into size stuff.
I know SW is always the minority of size fetish. Supposedly. Probably why it had a monthly schedule instead of every other month. And the raffle helps keeps things interesting between issues, but maybe some shorter stand alone comics, like 4 cell stories or just 2 or 3 pagers in between could be fun. Short, self contained shrinking stories (or shorter serialized stories even).

Honey, I'm just thrilled that their stuff isn't 90% foot content.

[Nropyub]

Honey, I'm just thrilled that their stuff isn't 90% foot content.

Can’t argue with that, but they have to do better than ‘not all feet’.

Barely any M/f sexual interactions. Latest comic is just another GTS comic that could have been on Giantess Fan.

[Prof Sai]

Yes, sadly I gave up on them a while ago. I can just do higher quality stuff on my own. All the endless penis riding is what I got tired of. And so many unlikeable characters. That one with the Shakespeare play might as well have been stick figures.

They've also got some nutcases running their discord. I posted a Miraculous Ladybug pic with the characters in their normal outfits, and some mod through a fit. When I pointed out that they had Totally Spies characters running around in the nude, her reply was that I should somehow "know the difference" and banned me. I can guess what this person's actual objection is, but they are too twisted to actually recognise it themselves.

[Enigma12]

Honestly I just stick around for two or three comics series I'm interested in or whatever pops up in their gallery that catches my eye every other month or so. Kind of a mixed bag as I think a number of their older comics are good.

[blackbat]

Honey, I'm just thrilled that their stuff isn't 90% foot content.

Can’t argue with that, but they have to do better than ‘not all feet’.

Barely any M/f sexual interactions. Latest comic is just another GTS comic that could have been on Giantess Fan.

I have a love/hate with feet, it's very confusing for me since day one, I am picky for some odd reason. Thankful for the lack of feet in the comics, when they do though, cannot think of an example I liked with a feet heavy comic from Shrink Fan. One Little Marble series, I have no clue why I kept going back to it. The traits of the feet in that are not appealing to me, but I am not the boss of the community, everyone is free to like what they like, I have my own odd thing with feet.

Favourite recent is 'Mini-Mistress,' nearly two years between both issues but Hmage does great artwork again.

Other series that were good:

• 'Small Fortune' had 5 issues, no new issues since December 2019, great series though.
• 'Life Diminished' series is decent, the story is good, the lack of intimacy was part of the story, still though, there was a BIG lack of it.
• 'The Dwindling' series was decent too, good combo of story and sex, the artwork kinda felt like it had a lack of detail, almost like a Renaissance watercolour painting.
• 'Upcoming Decent' is okay, just a little slow at times in both story and sexy scenes.

I think the only short-lived comic series that had a minimum setup in the first issue and then the second issue had a good payoff was The Invisible Girl, no need for a third issue, good story closed up nicely, the sex scenes are brilliant.

There were some great one-shots years ago, for me, they were:

• Shrink-O-Vision
• Sun, Surf, Shrunk
• Reduction of the Innocent
• Shortcake
• Little
• Operation Half Off (2 issue one-shot, but could have an issue 3 or a long series easily, kind of like Super Spy on Giantess Fan)
• Trek Through The Microverse

Others that all are meant to have sequels that still need them to me:

• Who's The Boss - excellent comic, classic SW trope, could be a good series (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since September 2016)
• Witches Gone Wild: Pixie Party - superb story, great potential for a series (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since May 2020 - written by Cezar Nix who still does work for Shrink Fan)
• A Sneak Peek - excellent comic, loved the SW character for her eccentric personality and cuteness (has a The End...?, no issue 2 since January 2022)
• Concert in a Minor Key - interesting, potential for a series, like a SW Columbo/Poirot detective series in a way (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since November 2019)
• Toonstruck! - fun scenario, setup for something in next issue (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since mid-July 2018)
• Little Mallet - great story, great potential for a Far East mythical comes to the everyday modern West fantasy Hollywood trope series (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since July 2019 - Hmage still does comics for the Fan company, so confused why this has not been done)
• Down The Drain - very good, almost SW trope-like, based on a popular SW webcomic trope (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since June 2019)

Least favourite was Boom Boom Shrink, I still do not fully understand the reasoning for that plot or why things happened, felt very forced and rushed.

I agree with Nropyub on the Super Retirement series. April 2026 had issue 7 come out, Issue 1 was in November 2022, with a to be continued, no Issue 2 until February 2024, then 5 issues since then, looking at Shrink Fan release history on other comic series, it's unheard of. For me, this forum thread in the SW community is the first one I have seen it mentioned from a user unrelated to Shrink Fan, and it's not a positive comment. No positives from me either, it's interesting but it's like a mainstream 18+ comic from a non-Marvel or DC house, also the plot has a confusing superhero surprising plot tropes that I think Marvel/DC rarely touch anymore, like a new superpower/trait out of nowhere thing. Is the series a big download for new issues or just a "filler" comic series, while others are made or something?

I think Prof Sai was on this thread when it happened, I remember on The Process Forum, Vanyard Vince used to post regularly on new issues from the Fan-websites in multiple sub-forums. I remember on the Shrink Fan one a few years ago, someone mentioned the lack of good content, then it started a discussion on the cons of Shrink Fan releases of comics for the monthly subscribers. Like why Giantess Fan get 2 or 3 releases a month and why Shrink Fan went to one release a month instead of two releases, or lack of a certain theme of SW rarely used, or repetition with stories. Then one user mentioned the number of comics released that finished with "END?" or "TO BE CONTINUED" and no sequels, which ignited the thread with users realising that it is a critical annoyance and vented their frustrations like being subscribed for a sequel for one or a few comics and nothing coming up or no updates if it will happen at all. Even The Process Forum mod/admin Qzar aka Shrink Fan's regular editor Cezar Nix stepped in to cool things down with a couple of answers. Maybe the demonic-sounding Discord mods might have had a fit that day, no reason for Prof Sai's banning though, sounds like the classic mod drunk with power on the smallest of things and being a mod of nothing major in the world.

Not seen another Shrink Fan or Giantess Fan update or active advert thread on any forum except for DeviantArt since the complaints. I did notice they stopped putting "END?" or "TO BE CONTINUED" on most releases unless it seems they were 100% sure there would be a sequel on the way, example, One Little Marble 1, no TO BE CONTINUED at the end, issue 2 comes out over two years later in October 2022, has a TO BE CONTINUED at the end, issue 3 coming out in about two weeks in July 2026.

I know one of the big problems in making comics like this is if they lose being able to hire the same illustrator/letterer/layout artist/etc who made the first issue to create a sequel. Some comics suffer from the change of style with sales easily, as seen with other vendors like ZZZ Comics. In this case with Shrink Fan, the number is very high for this repeating problem, so something is not working behind the scenes, but I do not know how the Fan-company runs, they just posts on new releases, no development, behind-the-scenes or sketch teasers of ideas or something. I don't need to know marketing 101 to know that regular posts or updates keeps up interest and higher hits for more subscribers, there are many free/nearly no-cost/low cost ways to do that. Galley commission raffles are great, lets the community be a part of the show. It can be very sporadic in releases. I remember there was none for Shrink Fan for about a year for some reason, never explained why, I know a pandemic happened but remote work was still a thing, especially for artists who pretty much pioneered it online.

Raso719's idea on some one-shot comic panel pages is a good shout though, also a good way to test a new or comic artist the Fan company has not used before.

[scidram]

Hey everyone!

Thank you for expressing your concerns about the comics at ShrinkFan, where I'm one of the editors. Please know that we appreciate and consider all feedback. Due to the varied interests in the shrinking woman fantasy, we acknowledge that every comic may not be everyone's cup of tea, but we strive for a diverse selection of content. Our monthly release schedule is determined by which comics have been completed, and our overall production schedule is determined by the scripts we have to choose from. Though our editors often contribute scripts, a significant amount are written by fans such as yourself, and we welcome new narrative voices and ideas. If there's a particular story or scenario you'd like to see illustrated, you're welcome to pitch an idea to us HERE. If approved, an editor--likely me--will reach out to you and assist you in formatting the idea into our standard 15-page script.

Thanks for your time. If you have any further questions, please send me a private message here or drop me an email at [email protected] .

[Dr.Minimizer]

That reminds me, there's something I need to do...

[Enigma12]

Well this should be interesting

[Nropyub]

The traits of the feet in that are not appealing to me, but I am not the boss of the community, everyone is free to like what they like, I have my own odd thing with feet.

I think this is a healthy point of view. The point of this post is not to say that we're upset because 100% of the content is geared to our specific checklist of needs. Some people are into feet. Some of those people are little women and big guys or big women and that's okay. I don't share it but like...let's not hold that mirror up. We're gonna have to be respectful of one another.

Favourite recent is 'Mini-Mistress,' nearly two years between both issues but Hmage does great artwork again.

I think the only short-lived comic series that had a minimum setup in the first issue and then the second issue had a good payoff was The Invisible Girl, no need for a third issue, good story closed up nicely, the sex scenes are brilliant.

Hmage is the best artist they've got for facial expressions and demonstrating action in the art. Vibrant colors too. I wish the proportions were a little more realistic (I'm actually less interested in the volleyball sized chest every woman he draws seems to have). Invisible Girl, Mini-Mistress and Reduction of the Innocent are all great entries (more of RotI below). Also, no one draws a cumshot like him, especially in Invisible Girl. The shot of the tiny woman from behind, her satisfied man looming in the distance like terrain, covered in his load, dwarfed by his manhood...it's just perfect. It doesn't have to be all dick-riding like Sai says. The aftermath, the foreplay and the scenery are all so important. Don't read this as me saying this is the only way to demonstrate intimacy in these stories or in real life, I'm just partial to it is all.

• Shrink-O-Vision
• Sun, Surf, Shrunk
• Reduction of the Innocent
• Shortcake
• Little
• Operation Half Off (2 issue one-shot, but could have an issue 3 or a long series easily, kind of like Super Spy on Giantess Fan)
• Trek Through The Microverse

Reduction of the Innocent was great, I just wish we had more time at 3 inches tall (or whatever), it's my favorite scale and Hmage's art is great. Once he picks up the little lady at the park bench I'm really happy for a few pages...would be better if she were stuck that way in my humble opinion.

Sun, Surf, Shrink was outstanding and notably all-women, so it's not just the lack of guys that bothers me. The focus felt like it was on tiny ladies. It was whacky innocent fun with tiny people. I really like when they accidentally shrank themselves and would have preferred if the main character stayed normal sized for effect.

Operation Half-Off always felt Half-Finished to me. But I'm not into the 50% scale, or the barbie doll scale. I like 1/12th scale and smaller down to 1/4" micro. Might just be a matter of taste so that kind of stuff is to be expected. I chalk this one up to trying to appeal to a large number of people with different tastes.

Others that all are meant to have sequels that still need them to me:

[*] Who's The Boss - excellent comic, classic SW trope, could be a good series (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since September 2016)
[*] Witches Gone Wild: Pixie Party - superb story, great potential for a series (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since May 2020 - written by Cezar Nix who still does work for Shrink Fan)
[*] A Sneak Peek - excellent comic, loved the SW character for her eccentric personality and cuteness (has a The End...?, no issue 2 since January 2022)
[*] Concert in a Minor Key - interesting, potential for a series, like a SW Columbo/Poirot detective series in a way (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since November 2019)
[*] Toonstruck! - fun scenario, setup for something in next issue (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since mid-July 2018)
[*] Little Mallet - great story, great potential for a Far East mythical comes to the everyday modern West fantasy Hollywood trope series (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since July 2019 - Hmage still does comics for the Fan company, so confused why this has not been done)
[*]Down The Drain - very good, almost SW trope-like, based on a popular SW webcomic trope (has a To Be Continued, no issue 2 since June 2019)[/list]

Lucky Mallet is bizarre to me. It was just abandoned completely. Hmage art pops, again, but went literally nowhere. Maybe the writer bailed?

The fact that Witches Gone Wild was abandoned is a sin. It was so good. Fairies as giants? Yes please. Again, maybe the writer bailed? I dunno.

Who's the Boss is a perfect SW/GTS story. Ripe for continuation or spin-offs. Hell, just do that scenario again with a nerdy guy that has had enough of his boss. Or maybe a boss lady that likes being cut down to size to relieve the stress.

Sneak Peek was good in the first half. Wasn't interested in the GTS content in this comic.

Concert in Minor Key was strange, it was all set up and then ditches. Why bother? Also, again...50% scale is kinda boring to me.

Down the Drain is basically just 4chan SW art expanded out. It was okay. But to me, the shrinking sequence is less important then what the character does after. So might be a taste thing. The thing is, you can do sequences in one or two pages and show everything that needs to be shown, so doing that over an entire issue and not doing anything else with it just seems like a waste.

Toonstruck! always felt more transform than shrinking to me.

Least favourite was Boom Boom Shrink, I still do not fully understand the reasoning for that plot or why things happened, felt very forced and rushed.

I had to look this one up. It is straight up GTS content. It's all about the bigger woman using power. Does not feel like SW content and the tiny could have been a guy with no change to story. I like what they did with it from a GTS content perspective (I enjoy both) but this doesn't feel like SW, to me.

I agree with Nropyub on the Super Retirement series.

Is the series a big download for new issues or just a "filler" comic series, while others are made or something?

It's so BLAND. 90% of the reason I made this post. It's all women, the background usually have little detail and there is no real sense of scale that is consistent. The stretchy one making a tiny person on a flesh leash is so weird and creepy to me, too. I honestly don't get who they have in mind for this one. I liked the first issue but I liked seeing the tiny house interior a little bit (would have preferred it to be scaled to her with things being "off" that don't scale well, but that's me).

I think Prof Sai was on this thread when it happened, I remember on The Process Forum, Vanyard Vince used to post regularly on new issues from the Fan-websites in multiple sub-forums. I remember on the Shrink Fan one a few years ago, someone mentioned the lack of good content, then it started a discussion on the cons of Shrink Fan releases of comics for the monthly subscribers. Like why Giantess Fan get 2 or 3 releases a month and why Shrink Fan went to one release a month instead of two releases, or lack of a certain theme of SW rarely used, or repetition with stories. Then one user mentioned the number of comics released that finished with "END?" or "TO BE CONTINUED" and no sequels, which ignited the thread with users realising that it is a critical annoyance and vented their frustrations like being subscribed for a sequel for one or a few comics and nothing coming up or no updates if it will happen at all. Even The Process Forum mod/admin Qzar aka Shrink Fan's regular editor Cezar Nix stepped in to cool things down with a couple of answers. Maybe the demonic-sounding Discord mods might have had a fit that day, no reason for Prof Sai's banning though, sounds like the classic mod drunk with power on the smallest of things and being a mod of nothing major in the world.

I had no idea of this drama at all, but I have never frequented the Process Forum. I will say that I completely understand that there is an economy of scale (HA!) and that GTS content simply sells more, so we have to pay the same to get less (or pay more to get the same, whichever). You can always wait a few months and try one month and catch up, and accept that it's slower or whatever. That I'm fine with.

The issue I have is that in the past year, since July 2025, 13 issues have come out and 11 of them are largely GTS/sw. I have GTS fan. I'm mostly happy with it. It delivers giantess content. I signed up for Shrink Fan for shrunk women, and would like to see them do more than hang out with giant women.

I know one of the big problems in making comics like this is if they lose being able to hire the same illustrator/letterer/layout artist/etc who made the first issue to create a sequel. Some comics suffer from the change of style with sales easily, as seen with other vendors like ZZZ Comics. In this case with Shrink Fan, the number is very high for this repeating problem, so something is not working behind the scenes, but I do not know how the Fan-company runs, they just posts on new releases, no development, behind-the-scenes or sketch teasers of ideas or something. I don't need to know marketing 101 to know that regular posts or updates keeps up interest and higher hits for more subscribers, there are many free/nearly no-cost/low cost ways to do that. Galley commission raffles are great, lets the community be a part of the show. It can be very sporadic in releases. I remember there was none for Shrink Fan for about a year for some reason, never explained why, I know a pandemic happened but remote work was still a thing, especially for artists who pretty much pioneered it online.

Yeah it feels like complete silence. Every time there are only two comics on the upcoming page I half expect it to be like hey we're done. Then another month gets announced.

Raso719's idea on some one-shot comic panel pages is a good shout though, also a good way to test a new or comic artist the Fan company has not used before.

I think this would work well in addition to the pinups (which are not ever pinups by any definition but should be called one-shots or whatever).

Hey everyone!
...

I didn't include the full quote to save space but will respond here:
I like that you're interested in feedback. I'm going to be completely honest here, in that I am airing a disappointment but I'm in no way saying I could do better. I'm not a writer or an artist. But I am a consumer, and I'm not thrilled with the product. I won't speak for everyone else but I will suggest the following, with the disclaimer that I'm not an expert, a genius, particularly intelligent, trustworthy or even remotely accountable for my words or actions.

• 1. Too much set up for how infrequently the stories are continued and updated. Get to the action faster. GTS fan can do longer set up (and, notably, doesn't in my opinion).
  2. More male content, more intimacy, and more variety in that intimacy. We already have a GTS fan. If the comic could easily go in both occasionally that's fine, and unavoidable if you're being varied in the stories. If the majority of the comics for a year could have been in both then you've kinda lost direction.
  3. Emphasize the smallness of the characters in their settings. Show, don't tell. A Weekend Alone excels at this for GTS content. Looming shots, oversized objects, zoomed out shots.

I say this all with love and as a longtime fan and supporter, and as someone who wants us fans of shrunken women to see members of our community succeed!

[scidram]

Hey everyone!
...

I didn't include the full quote to save space but will respond here:
I like that you're interested in feedback. I'm going to be completely honest here, in that I am airing a disappointment but I'm in no way saying I could do better. I'm not a writer or an artist. But I am a consumer, and I'm not thrilled with the product. I won't speak for everyone else but I will suggest the following, with the disclaimer that I'm not an expert, a genius, particularly intelligent, trustworthy or even remotely accountable for my words or actions.

• 1. Too much set up for how infrequently the stories are continued and updated. Get to the action faster. GTS fan can do longer set up (and, notably, doesn't in my opinion).
  2. More male content, more intimacy, and more variety in that intimacy. We already have a GTS fan. If the comic could easily go in both occasionally that's fine, and unavoidable if you're being varied in the stories. If the majority of the comics for a year could have been in both then you've kinda lost direction.
  3. Emphasize the smallness of the characters in their settings. Show, don't tell. A Weekend Alone excels at this for GTS content. Looming shots, oversized objects, zoomed out shots.

I say this all with love and as a longtime fan and supporter, and as someone who wants us fans of shrunken women to see members of our community succeed!

Thank you for the feedback. I will bring the suggestions to the team, and we'll do what we can with the batch of scripts we have.

[Enigma12]

Honestly the only real gripe I have with Shrink fan comics was never a continuation of that was Down With Skeptics. Honestly looked like to me that could have had a second part was Down With Skeptics. Seems to have a definite end but always rereading felt like it it was.just like a half. Other than that I have no real complaints, well ones that hadn't already been pointed out by others here. Am curious what future comics are going to be like.

[Prof Sai]

Hi Sidram!

Was it you I once asked about me doing an issue of ShrinkFan? I know the haters wouldn't be happy, but I'm sure readers would be.

[scidram]

Hi Sidram!

Was it you I once asked about me doing an issue of ShrinkFan? I know the haters wouldn't be happy, but I'm sure readers would be.

I believe I did once ask you if there was a story idea you had in mind. We really do want the fans to be able to see their shrinking woman fantasies illustrated. Somewhere further up this thread is a link to pitch an idea.

[blackbat]

The traits of the feet ...

I think this is a healthy point of view. The point of this post is not to say that we're upset because 100% of the content is geared to our specific checklist of needs. Some people are into feet. Some of those people are little women and big guys or big women and that's okay. I don't share it but like...let's not hold that mirror up. We're gonna have to be respectful of one another.

Thank you, I completely agree, it's my view on this, we are all pretty much anonymous in the SW community, no need to take shots at each other, we share the same love of the fetish, but we are all still different. We are not all gonna agree, like another thing about me, I do not like gore/vore involving an SW, I truly do not like it and feel bad for the SW every time I accidentally end up reading a comic/story that has gore/vore on an SW that perishes. Again, that's me, I am not demanding or damning for part of the SW community, it's just not my thing, I move and do not interact with it.

Favourite recent is 'Mini-Mistress.....

.....a good payoff was The Invisible Girl, no need for a third issue, go.....

Hmage is the best artist they've got for facial expressions and demonstrating action in the art. Vibrant colors too. I wish the proportions were a little more realistic (I'm actually less interested in the volleyball sized chest every woman he draws seems to have). Invisible Girl, Mini-Mistress and Reduction of the Innocent are all great entries (more of RotI below). Also, no one draws a cumshot like him, especially in Invisible Girl. The shot of the tiny woman from behind, her satisfied man looming in the distance like terrain, covered in his load, dwarfed by his manhood...it's just perfect. It doesn't have to be all dick-riding like Sai says. The aftermath, the foreplay and the scenery are all so important. Don't read this as me saying this is the only way to demonstrate intimacy in these stories or in real life, I'm just partial to it is all.

Again, 100% this, even with Reduction of the Innocent, can be a different victim or mishap every issue, like a serial crime drama like Law & Order but SW mishaps, ohhh that's not a bad idea you know. Look at the Law & Order franchise, it's massive, monstrous, bound to have inspirations for SW version of stories. Law and Order: Shrunken Victims Unit, I know what the main theme of SVU is, but I am not using those crimes, just messing with the title there. Looked at outside Hmage work from the GTS and SW community, they look to have an interest in other fetishes but it's clear they pull out all the stocks for the Fan-comics. The art style is joyful to read, it instantly adds a 10% positive buffer for any comic. "aftermath, the foreplay and the scenery are all so important" - might be the wrong thing to say, but could Hmage be the fetish equivalent to Studio Ghibli because if you are a fan of Ghibli, you know everything always has extra to each scene, Extra story bits that are not filler but act like snippet fillers that still add to the story, then the details of the scenary, there's so much those film do not need to draw or animate but they do and it's add to their amazing success.

• ...ion
• ...rf, Shrunk
• Reduction of the Innocent
• ...ake
• ...tle
• Operation Half Off 1 & 2....
• ...erse

Reduction of the Innocent was great, I just wish we had more time at 3 inches tall (or whatever), it's my favorite scale and Hmage's art is great. Once he picks up the little lady at the park bench I'm really happy for a few pages...would be better if she were stuck that way in my humble opinion.

As mentioned above it has potential for more or a Law & Order style reboot. To add, it could be that, the series is not stuck with one writer, can be a new writer per issue for a one-shot story, but the same detectives and crime staff like each Law & Order franchise per issue story.

Sun, Surf, Shrink was outstanding and notably all-women, so it's not just the lack of guys that bothers me. The focus felt like it was on tiny ladies. It was whacky innocent fun with tiny people. I really like when they accidentally shrank themselves and would have preferred if the main character stayed normal sized for effect.

It's not very far from the Bully story issue in a way, no men there but more women in this one

Operation Half-Off always felt Half-Finished to me. But I'm not into the 50% scale, or the barbie doll scale. I like 1/12th scale and smaller down to 1/4" micro. Might just be a matter of taste so that kind of stuff is to be expected. I chalk this one up to trying to appeal to a large number of people with different tastes.

I feel 2 more issues could have come from this, but again, like another Shrink Fan issue, this could be worked like Giantess Fan's Super Spy series in a way.

Others that all are meant to have sequels that still need them to me:

[*] Who's The Boss
[*] Witches Gone Wild: Pixie Party
[*] A Sneak Peek
[*] Concert in a Minor Key
[*] Toonstruck!
[*] Little Mallet
[*]Down The Drain [/list]

Lucky Mallet is bizarre to me. It was just abandoned completely. Hmage art pops, again, but went literally nowhere. Maybe the writer bailed?

Writer must have which is a shame, Lucky Mallet that had a lot of potential and great possible SW interactions with the characters in confrontation and not.

The fact that Witches Gone Wild was abandoned is a sin. It was so good. Fairies as giants? Yes please. Again, maybe the writer bailed? I dunno.

Preach, out of this list I did, the story is truly fantastic, and by far the one that really needs a sequel, it's WILD (pun intended) that's no issue 2.

Who's the Boss is a perfect SW/GTS story. Ripe for continuation or spin-offs. Hell, just do that scenario again with a nerdy guy that has had enough of his boss. Or maybe a boss lady that likes being cut down to size to relieve the stress.

See that makes me think of ZZZ comics' "Magnifier" series with the nerdy guy to The Dwindling series for the boss lady who likes to cut down in size for stress.

Sneak Peek was good in the first half. Wasn't interested in the GTS content in this comic.

Fair point, the character design of her in look and personality is very cute though, pure chaos

Concert in Minor Key was strange, it was all set up and then ditches. Why bother? Also, again...50% scale is kinda boring to me.

I see the 50% scale again, for me, 50% kinda reflects close to real life, I see so many very tall men with very short non-dwarven women couples nowadays aged 40 and below.

Down the Drain is basically just 4chan SW art expanded out. It was okay. But to me, the shrinking sequence is less important then what the character does after. So might be a taste thing. The thing is, you can do sequences in one or two pages and show everything that needs to be shown, so doing that over an entire issue and not doing anything else with it just seems like a waste.

Yes, it's expanded on many parts though but the ending I would like to see a sequel, an SW cliffhanger while she is in mid-pleasure

Toonstruck! always felt more transform than shrinking to me.

Actually yeah, I see your point there, it goes from normal comic then jumps closer to those porn comics of real cartoon IPs and the last page sounds like it would go for into the cartoon IP kinda thing, less SW.

Least favourite was Boom Boom Shrink...

I had to look this one up. It is straight up GTS content. It's all about the bigger woman using power. Does not feel like SW content and the tiny could have been a guy with no change to story. I like what they did with it from a GTS content perspective (I enjoy both) but this doesn't feel like SW, to me.

You raise an excellent point, if there's a balance of a comic between GTS & SW, this comic sways a fair bit into GTS, which kinda makes the comic belong on Giantess Fan if it did not have that title.

I agree with Nropyub on the Super Retirement series.

Is the series a big download ...

It's so BLAND. 90% of the reason I made this post. It's all women, the background usually have little detail and there is no real sense of scale that is consistent. The stretchy one making a tiny person on a flesh leash is so weird and creepy to me, too. I honestly don't get who they have in mind for this one. I liked the first issue but I liked seeing the tiny house interior a little bit (would have preferred it to be scaled to her with things being "off" that don't scale well, but that's me).

Great points on this, thinking about the first issue, with a few step it could have been a superhero version of Shrink Fan's Better Night , which to mention could have a sequel too or not, it depends on the sequel story.

I think Prof Sai was on this thread when it happened, I remember on The Process Forum, Vanyard Vince used to post...

I had no idea of this drama at all, but I have never frequented the Process Forum. I will say that I completely understand that there is an economy of scale (HA!) and that GTS content simply sells more, so we have to pay the same to get less (or pay more to get the same, whichever). You can always wait a few months and try one month and catch up, and accept that it's slower or whatever. That I'm fine with.

The issue I have is that in the past year, since July 2025, 13 issues have come out and 11 of them are largely GTS/sw. I have GTS fan. I'm mostly happy with it. It delivers giantess content. I signed up for Shrink Fan for shrunk women, and would like to see them do more than hang out with giant women.

Well, The Process Forum exists on Discord now, and I check once in a while. The forum up to around the mid-10s was very good for the Growth and Shrinking sub-forums, wish I saved more posts on it, some great content was posted there. Even Q & A with MissaX when she still did the legendary size fetish stuff on C4S.

The shrunk women hanging out with giant women kinda reminds me of a couple of legendary SW artist Toyogub's "koonago" works, a couple of them have scenes of shrunken women but all at different sizes, they are superb.

I know one of the big problems in making comics like this is if they lose being able to hire the same illustrator/letterer/layout artist/etc who made the first issue to create a sequel. Some comics suffer from the change of style with sales...

Yeah it feels like complete silence. Every time there are only two comics on the upcoming page I half expect it to be like hey we're done. Then another month gets announced.

Same, it does feel like, oh it's been two upcoming comics for a while, has Shrink Fan ran out of steam, then sometime mid-month-ish, new upcoming comic.

Raso719's idea on some one-shot comic panel pages is a good shout though, also...

I think this would work well in addition to the pinups (which are not ever pinups by any definition but should be called one-shots or whatever).

Agreed.

Hey everyone!
...

I didn't include the full quote to save space but will respond here:
I like that you're interested in feedback. I'm going to be completely honest here, in that I am airing a disappointment but I'm in no way saying I could do better. I'm not a writer or an artist. But I am a consumer, and I'm not thrilled with the product. I won't speak for everyone else but I will suggest the following, with the disclaimer that I'm not an expert, a genius, particularly intelligent, trustworthy or even remotely accountable for my words or actions.

• 1. Too much set up for how infrequently the stories are continued and updated. Get to the action faster. GTS fan can do longer set up (and, notably, doesn't in my opinion).
  2. More male content, more intimacy, and more variety in that intimacy. We already have a GTS fan. If the comic could easily go in both occasionally that's fine, and unavoidable if you're being varied in the stories. If the majority of the comics for a year could have been in both then you've kinda lost direction.
  3. Emphasize the smallness of the characters in their settings. Show, don't tell. A Weekend Alone excels at this for GTS content. Looming shots, oversized objects, zoomed out shots.

I say this all with love and as a longtime fan and supporter, and as someone who wants us fans of shrunken women to see members of our community succeed!

1. "Get to the action faster." - yes, and yes Giantess Fan can afford to do alonger set up this with the rate of comics being released but they normally get straight into the action.
2. I will say the most variety in SW intimacy recently was the sequel to Mini-Mistress, it was excellent. A Royal Mistake 1 & 2, is probably the closest recent to this but there's a gap in variety by quite a margin, A Royal Mistake is good but the SW intimacies feel drawn out with only one thing happening with each pairing in a way. I did just look back on the Shrink Fan website and completely forgot Love Is Equal at Every Size came out, apologies, it didn't come to mind for a recent variety SW intimacy example, I think A Royal Mistake came to mind because of the more than one pairing.
3. A Weekend Alone is one I avoid but from the previews I have seen, I see your point here.

Yeah, longtime supporter here too just hate to see a good thing go to waste when more community input can make it so much better

TO ADD

Great contribution, Nropyub, appreciate all the individual replies, and I replied out of courtesy and interest back but wow that was a lot of typing, too much in my book but worth it, just do not want to do it again. Brain a little frazzled, haha. hope I helped the discussion, I feel it's for the good of the SW community who has interest.

[blackbat]

Hi Sidram!

Was it you I once asked about me doing an issue of ShrinkFan? I know the haters wouldn't be happy, but I'm sure readers would be.

I believe I did once ask you if there was a story idea you had in mind. We really do want the fans to be able to see their shrinking woman fantasies illustrated. Somewhere further up this thread is a link to pitch an idea.

Woah, not even one Prof Sai-written comic on Shrink Fan? That's truly surprising to me, I thought I had mentioned at least two comics above that could have been a Prof Sai-written piece, and i hadn't noticed, but I assumed one of those must have. I feel a Prof Sai would be interesting. Very curious about what it could be.

Do not know why, but I feel you could write a very good comic of a SW that solo shrinks themselves out of their own fantasy and gets intimate with themselves? Then the cliffhanger of being discovered by a female flatmate? Similar scenarios to this would be Shrink Fan's Feeling Low (which is cute but a bummer at the same time), Down The Drain, but SW didn't expect any of the shrinking while being very self-intimate with themself, they are the only two that come to mind. Not much of that kind of SW story with recent SW content in general, unless I missed something?

Either way I feel a Prof Sai story into a SW comic would be a great addition to the community

[Nropyub]

IN GENERAL

Thanks for replying so thoroughly! I think we line up on a lot. I find myself skipping the violent stuff too but it's so prevalent that sometimes 'skipping it' means choosing specific pages to enjoy.

I think we should again acknowledge how cool is was of Scidram to come out and talk with us. It's always very important to remember that there are hardworking people on the other end of the media we consume and purchase, even if we are a little frustrated with it. Thank you for doing that.

[Nropyub]

Again, 100% this, even with Reduction of the Innocent, can be a different victim or mishap every issue, like a serial crime drama like Law & Order but SW mishaps, ohhh that's not a bad idea you know. Look at the Law & Order franchise, it's massive, monstrous, bound to have inspirations for SW version of stories. Law and Order: Shrunken Victims Unit, I know what the main theme of SVU is, but I am not using those crimes, just messing with the title there. Looked at outside Hmage work from the GTS and SW community, they look to have an interest in other fetishes but it's clear they pull out all the stocks for the Fan-comics. The art style is joyful to read, it instantly adds a 10% positive buffer for any comic. "aftermath, the foreplay and the scenery are all so important" - might be the wrong thing to say, but could Hmage be the fetish equivalent to Studio Ghibli because if you are a fan of Ghibli, you know everything always has extra to each scene, Extra story bits that are not filler but act like snippet fillers that still add to the story, then the details of the scenary, there's so much those film do not need to draw or animate but they do and it's add to their amazing success.

I actually just submitted a pitch to Shrink Fan for a series that is ambiguous in length because each chapter is a new SW talking about their lives in a world where people can be shrunk permanently. Every issue is a chapter, every chapter is a new cast and the theme of each story is completely different.